0 COMMENTS

The Best Game I Can’t Remember

Warhammer Fantasy: Dark Elves vs Dwarves. Photograph by RedCraig, cropped, CC BY-SA 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons.

Every now and again somebody asks me why I still play with toy soldiers.

It’s a fair question. I’m fifty-four years old. By most people’s standards, I should probably have found a grown-up hobby by now.

For years I never really thought about the answer. Then, not so long ago, I caught myself asking exactly the same question. Not because I was getting bored. If anything, I enjoy miniature wargaming more now than I ever have.

One game in particular kept coming back to me, from when I was fifteen. The strange thing is, I can’t remember who won, or much of what happened once we started rolling dice. What I can remember is almost everything surrounding it.

My friend Quentin had invited me over one Saturday afternoon. He’d somehow managed to fit a full-size table tennis table into his bedroom, and even more incredibly, there was enough room to walk all the way around it. It was covered in green cloth, with homemade hills and woods, and our two painted armies waiting to be deployed. Kate Bush, Jean-Michel Jarre and Mike Oldfield played quietly in the background. Quentin had chosen the music because he thought it suited the battle we were about to fight. I still think that’s a better use for a table tennis table than table tennis.

I’d spent months reading Warhammer Fantasy Battles. I knew the rules almost by heart and had filled notebooks with army lists and ideas. But I’d never seen anyone my own age approach the hobby quite like Quentin had.

His army was Elves and mine was Dwarfs. His regiments carried hand-painted banners showing which lord each unit belonged to. My Dwarfs had nothing like that. I did have a very carefully worked out army list. If I saw that table today, I’d probably notice every wonky hill and badly flocked hedge. At the time, I thought it was the best thing I’d ever seen.

I spent the walk home replaying the afternoon in my head. By the time I got back, I wasn’t interested in dinner. I went straight upstairs, pulled out my Dwarf army list and threw it in the bin.

I got out all the Dwarf heroes who led my units and started giving them names. Then I went through their command groups, finding standard bearers and musicians, adding champions where needed and working out who all these characters were. I was drawing heavily on Tolkien and the Dwarf adventurers I’d created for D&D. Josef Bugman was there too, the original version, leading his Dwarf Rangers.

And, of course, I started painting banners for all my units. I wasn’t going to let Quentin’s Elves have all the fun.

I spent the rest of that weekend starting again. I’d gone to Quentin’s house to play Warhammer and come home with a completely different idea of how I wanted to enjoy the hobby.

Not long afterwards I went away to boarding school. Life moved on, as it tends to when you’re a teenager. I still played plenty of roleplaying games, but my miniatures stayed at home and wargaming slipped into the background for a while.

A few years later, I found myself working in Games Workshop retail, and suddenly I was surrounded by the hobby every day. What I remember most about working in those shops is how much time we spent talking about games. There was no internet as we know it, no forums or Facebook groups. If you wanted to discuss a rule or an idea for an army, you found somebody else who was interested and started talking.

By lunchtime, somebody usually had a copy of Warhammer Fantasy Battles open on the counter because we’d started arguing about something. Customers would join in, somebody would insist the answer was hidden somewhere in an old White Dwarf, and before long we’d already decided what we were playing after the shop shut.

During quieter moments we’d paint reinforcements, convert miniatures we’d bought with our staff discount or stand around an open rulebook debating a paragraph that probably wasn’t as complicated as we were making it. Most evenings, a few of us would stay behind for a game. The next morning we’d be back again, discussing what had happened the night before and planning the next battle before we’d even opened the doors.

I loved being surrounded by all of that. There was always another army to collect, something to paint or a game somebody wanted to try.

I still enjoy that side of the hobby enormously. My phone regularly fills up with photographs of painted armies, battle reports, rules questions and messages from people who simply want to show me what they’ve been working on. I get just as much pleasure from seeing somebody else’s army come together as I do from playing a game myself, particularly when they’ve approached something in a way I hadn’t considered.

Occasionally, one of those messages takes me straight back to Quentin’s bedroom and that Saturday afternoon. I often wonder whether he remembers the game at all. To him, it might have been just another Saturday spent playing Warhammer with a friend.

I still couldn’t tell you who won. But I’m fairly sure my Dwarfs would have given a better account of themselves if they’d had fancy banners like Quentin’s Elves.

Comments

Comments are moderated before they appear.

No comments yet.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

Game Design

Why some rules need changing, some problems begin with the battlefield, and why players share responsibility for the games they create together.

Game Design

From Whittington Castle to a disputed manor: why medieval lords took up arms, how they asserted their authority, and what their quarrels suggest for The Barons’ War.

Rules

Optional weather rules for The Barons’ War Second Edition, with snow, sleet, rain, fog and extreme heat ready for playtesting.

FROM THE BLACK DESK

Subscribe to my occasional newsletter for notes from my desk about games I’m designing, things I’m playing, miniatures, the hobby and new writing from the site. I promise to only send the good stuff - no spam here!