THE BARONS’ WAR

0 COMMENTS

When the Rules Meet the Table

Action Token illustrations: Steve Beckett.

If you’ve played The Barons’ War, you’ll be familiar with the different coloured Action Tokens. Each has its own name and a lovely illustration by Steve Beckett, inspired by medieval manuscript illuminations. What you might not know is why they’re all different.

In one of the earliest versions of the game, a Group couldn’t perform the same Action more than once in a Round. The tokens were designed to make this easy to follow. You could look across the tabletop, see which Actions a Group had already performed and know what it could still do if activated again. Steve did a wonderful job with the illustrations, and I was delighted with how they turned out.

Then playtesting revealed a problem. Preventing Groups from repeating Actions wasn’t really adding anything worthwhile. It was another restriction to remember, and allowing players to choose the same Action again made the game flow better. We enjoyed playing it more without the restriction.

I should probably have removed the rule sooner, but I’d already commissioned the artwork, and I really liked those tokens. So I persevered with the mechanic longer than I should have. Eventually, the restriction went, but the different tokens stayed.

The amusing thing is that we could now use a single type of token to represent any Action. Broken and Weary would still need separate markers because they’re conditions affecting a Group rather than Actions it has performed. There’s no longer much mechanical reason for the different Action Tokens, but I still love Steve’s designs. I’m certainly not proposing we get rid of them now!

You Can’t Write a Rule for Everything

However carefully I work through a rulebook, somebody will eventually put their Warriors into a situation I hadn’t anticipated. Sometimes it’s an unusual combination of rules. Other times it’s something that seems perfectly obvious once somebody points it out.

I’ve tried to cover as much as reasonably possible in The Barons’ War. I want players to have clear rules for the important parts of the game, without constantly having to invent solutions. But there’s a limit to how far you can take that. You could fill a rulebook with exceptions for increasingly unlikely situations and still find something you’d missed. At some point, all that additional detail starts getting in the way of playing.

I wanted The Barons’ War to provide a narrative experience, where the battle develops on the tabletop and players have some freedom to deal with unexpected situations. That doesn’t mean ignoring the rules whenever they’re inconvenient. It means recognising that there will occasionally be circumstances they don’t explicitly cover.

That’s why I included guidance in the Second Edition rulebook for situations where players cannot agree on how something should work. Principle 10 of the Core Principles asks players to use good sense. If they still cannot agree, they roll a die, with the highest result deciding how to resolve the situation for the moment. They can then carry on playing and consult the rules once the game has finished.

I’d much rather two players resolve an unusual situation sensibly and finish their battle than spend twenty minutes arguing over something they might never encounter again. If the same difficulty keeps arising, however, that’s something I need to investigate.

Is the Rule Actually the Problem?

The Barons’ War Facebook group is a great way of finding out what people are experiencing. I regularly get involved in discussions, and players contact me directly by email as well. When the same question or complaint keeps appearing, I take notice. Sometimes the wording needs clarifying, an interaction has been overlooked or we discover that a rule isn’t working as intended.

Ranged Attacks are a good example of why I don’t assume every complaint calls for a rules change. I’ve lost count of how many times somebody has told me that shooting is overpowered in The Barons’ War. I understand why people raise it. Shooting can be extremely effective, and I suspect it often was historically as well.

But I’ve never played a game of The Barons’ War where I’ve felt shooting was overpowered. Not once. And I’m not saying that simply because I wrote the rules.

When somebody raises the issue, I want to understand what happened during their game. One of the first things I look at is how they’ve set up their battlefield. Interestingly, one of the most common responses from other players in the Facebook group is, “Are you using enough terrain?”

There’s a good reason that question comes up so often. Second Edition recommends that a normal 4’ x 3’ battlefield has at least twelve pieces of Area Terrain or terrain that blocks Line of Sight, spread across the table. It also asks players to examine the finished battlefield together and make any adjustments they think would improve the game before deploying.

If most of your scenery is arranged around the outside, leaving a large open space through the middle, you’re giving archers and crossbowmen a considerable advantage. Low walls and hedges might make shooting more difficult, but they don’t necessarily stop anyone from seeing their targets. If your archers can see almost the entire battlefield without leaving their deployment area, I would probably move a house before I started rewriting the shooting rules. I’ve written more about this in How to Set Up a Table for The Barons’ War.

Photograph by Andy Hobday. Miniatures by Wargames Atlantic, painted by Steve Beckett

There’s also the question of how people build their retinues. I’ve deliberately given players plenty of freedom, but I recognise that some groups would prefer a limit on the number of missile troops they can bring. That’s why the Second Edition FAQ includes an optional restriction: no more than one-third of a retinue’s points may be spent on Groups armed with ranged weapons.

It’s there for players who feel they need it. If you and your regular opponents can’t quite trust yourselves not to squeeze in another Group of archers, you’ve got a perfectly sensible way of setting a limit without imposing it on everybody else.

I don’t dismiss concerns about shooting, and I want people to keep raising them. But before changing the effectiveness of a weapon, I think we need to understand whether the problem comes from the rules or from the circumstances in which the game is being played.

Players have some responsibility for the games they create together. The retinues they choose, the terrain they place and the sort of battle they agree to play all influence what happens once the game begins.

When a Rule Really Does Need Changing

One rule I’ve been reconsidering is how Groups cross obstacles in The Barons’ War. It’s something I’ve had in mind for quite a while, particularly while developing the forthcoming sourcebook, The Barons’ War: Siege & Urban Warfare. I’ve written about the book and what I’m trying to achieve with it in How Do You Turn a Medieval Siege into a Tabletop Game?

During Second Edition playtesting, I think we oversimplified the crossing mechanic. We ended up requiring all the Warriors in a Group to cross an obstacle during the same Action. It was straightforward to explain, but it meant that a Group either crossed together or didn’t cross at all.

As I’ve worked on battles in streets and around buildings for Siege & Urban Warfare, that restriction has become increasingly difficult to work with. I want Groups to be able to make the hard yards over terrain. Some Warriors might have managed to get across a wall while others are still trying to follow. With the existing rule, that simply isn’t possible.

Photograph by Andy Hobday. Miniatures by Wargames Atlantic, painted by Steve Beckett

I’ve therefore proposed allowing Warriors to cross obstacles individually, provided the relevant movement and Coherency requirements are met. It gives Groups more freedom to negotiate difficult terrain, particularly when fighting around buildings and walls.

That might sound like a fairly straightforward change, but it has consequences elsewhere in the rules. Charges, Defensive Positions and Forced Back moves all need to account for Warriors being on different sides of an obstacle. Changing one paragraph without considering those interactions would be asking for trouble.

I’ve published the proposed changes in Groups Crossing Obstacles in The Barons’ War, along with the related rules that need testing.

I’m not interested in changing published rules every time somebody suggests an alternative. I’ve encountered plenty of ideas that sound excellent when you’re discussing them, only to discover they create entirely different problems once they’re played. Equally, I don’t think a rule should remain unchanged simply because it’s already appeared in a printed book.

What Sort of Game Do You Want to Play?

I’ve always wanted The Barons’ War to give players freedom when building their retinues. Some enjoy researching a particular medieval lord and putting together a force that represents his household. Others are more interested in exploring the combinations available in the army lists and finding effective ways of using them.

I’m comfortable with players approaching the game differently, but I do think it’s worth discussing what you both want from a battle before you begin. Two players with very different expectations can have a rather frustrating afternoon, even when they’re both following the rules correctly.

Tournament play brings different considerations. Players may be facing opponents they’ve never met, with limited time to complete their games and results contributing towards an overall competition. In those circumstances, additional restrictions and a more prescriptive framework make sense.

That’s why The Barons’ War has a standard tournament rules pack. Mark Vance, our recognised tournament organiser in the UK, has been running Barons’ War tournaments for several years. He’s developed the pack through those events, adjusting it in response to what happens on the tabletop and the feedback he receives from players. Mark is also a key playtester, which makes his experience particularly useful when we’re discussing the rules.

The tournament pack gives players a common set of restrictions and expectations before they arrive at an event. But I don’t want to impose every tournament restriction on somebody playing a narrative game with friends. The two approaches can happily exist alongside one another.

The proposed crossing obstacles changes still need more games before I can decide whether they should replace what’s in the rulebook. If they improve the game, I’ll make the change. If they create other problems, we’ll have another look. That’s part of my responsibility when I’m writing the rules.

But I can’t decide what sort of battle you and your opponent want to play, and I can’t guarantee you’ll both enjoy it simply by adding another page to the rulebook. That’s something you need to work out together.

By the time you put down your first Action Token, you’ve already made some of the most important decisions about the game you’re going to have.

Comments

Comments are moderated before they appear.

No comments yet.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

Game Design

From Whittington Castle to a disputed manor: why medieval lords took up arms, how they asserted their authority, and what their quarrels suggest for The Barons’ War.

Rules

Optional weather rules for The Barons’ War Second Edition, with snow, sleet, rain, fog and extreme heat ready for playtesting.

Projects

How I built William d’Aubigny’s first 500 points for The Barons’ War Second Edition, from his household Knights to the Green Levy, with the painted retinue and downloadable army list.

FROM THE BLACK DESK

Subscribe to my occasional newsletter for notes from my desk about games I’m designing, things I’m playing, miniatures, the hobby and new writing from the site. I promise to only send the good stuff - no spam here!